Naked City Pizza Shop What does 15 years of cooking experience and a need for authentic buffalo New York pizzeria fare get you?? The Naked City Pizza Shop is what it gets you. Built from day one to be the most authentic buffalo pizzeria west of Hertel avenue, Naked City Pizza Shop does it all from scratch. We make the dough, the sauce, the sausage, cheeses, and dressings everyday from fresh ingredients for you! Come into Naked City Pizza Shop for that 'back home' feel and try our chicken wings, chicken finger subs, and beef on weck and don't forget the pizza and more. We also are proud to show every buffalo bills and Sabres game right here at our shop. So come on in, 'mangia' and remember the food that makes us all think of back home! Order Online Payment Options